9 Best Pineapple Juice Substitutes

When you say pineapple juice, I hear high school spring break. I visited grandma’s house every spring, and she would give me freshly made fruit juice with breakfast every day.

Now I don’t always drink fresh juice, but I try to keep pineapple juice in the fridge for a quick smoothie or pina colada, depending on my mood.

And when I am out of pineapple juice, I have a list of pineapple juice substitutes to make satisfying recipes.

So let’s explore my colorful list of pineapple juice substitutes such as Mango Juice, Orange Juice, Lemon Juice, Guava Juice, Passion Fruit Juice, Papaya Juice, and more.

Keep reading to know how you can substitute pineapple juice with these alternatives. But first…

What is Pineapple Juice?

Pineapple Juice Substitutes

Well, pineapples look and taste exotic and grow primarily in warm tropical regions. These unique fruits are native to South America.

However, pineapples are cultivated in many countries now. The world’s most significant supply of pineapples comes from Thailand. 

Ripe pineapples are processed to make sweet yellow juice with a hint of sourness. Therefore, the flavor of pineapples is only prominent in ripe pineapples. On the other hand, unripe green pineapples are very sour and do not have any sweetness.

Pineapple juice is used in many cultures worldwide as a juice and an ingredient to flavor recipes. I love drinks that have the smell and taste of pineapples. The place I don’t want to see pineapples is on a pizza topping.

9 Best Pineapple Juice Substitutes

1. Fresh Pineapples

Fresh Pineapple

Suppose you don’t have pineapple juice for your recipe. But if you have ripped beautiful pineapples in the fruit section of your kitchen, you can easily make pure pineapple juice and enjoy the sweet and tangy delight. 

To make pineapple juice, peel the exotic skin and chop the pineapple. Now put it in a blender with half a glass of water and 1-2 tablespoons of sugar and blend. Once bending is over, take out the mash and strain the juice into a container.

And make delicious recipes or drink it as it is to beat the heat. If you have a juicer, you can put the chopped pineapples in it and make a pure solution for your recipes.

While adding water and sugar to the pineapple, you have to decide what texture and flavor you need.

For a thick consistency, you can adjust the water. And if you need a sugar-free version, don’t add sugar. You can use honey as a healthy sweetener instead of sugar.

2. Mango Juice

Mango Juice

Another fruit that screams spring-summer is mango. Mangoes are an exotic fruit that can substitute pineapple juice perfectly for marinating. In addition, Mango juice is naturally sweet, so you don’t have to add any extra sugar.

Mango juice is a vital source of Beta carotene, Vitamin C, Potassium, and other nutrients, making it a healthy replacement for pineapple juice. However, ripe mangoes do not always have a tangy hint.

So if you have sweet mango juice, add apple cider according to your taste and easily substitute pineapple juice in your coleslaw recipe.

3. Orange Juice

Orange Juice

Pick up those oranges if you are making ham and don’t have any pineapple juice left. Oranges are one of the most commonly consumed fruits around the globe. 

It has an equal balance of sweet and sour like pineapples. To enhance the sourness, add one tablespoon of lime juice to one cup of orange juice.

I always make orange juice at home, as it does not need any added components. And industrial versions add sugar, salt, and other preservatives that alter the natural flavors of oranges.

While making orange juice at home, don’t forget to taste one clove of each orange and only put the ones with a similar taste.

4. Lemon Juice

Lemon Juice

Lemon juice is packed with health benefits. It is one of the most readily available options of all pineapple juice substitutes. Lemon juice is widely used to replace pineapple juice to marinate meat, garnish salad, etc.

If you wish to use it in other recipes, add sugar or honey to sweet flavor. While using other sweet juices, you can squeeze a lemon in them to add a tangy hint.

Both lemon and lime juice serves the purpose well as a pineapple juice substitute.

5. Guava Juice

Guava Juice

Guavas are exotic, delicious, and a great source of antioxidants. To substitute pineapple juice, you need unripe guava juice. Ripe guavas have a prominent sweet taste, and you will have to add a sour component. 

If you use unripe guava juice, you will get a sweet and sour flavor balance that can complement your dish, just like pineapple juice. I love the taste that green guava juice adds to my summer drinks.

6. Apple Juice

Apple Juice

You can make apple juice at home or buy pure apple juice from the store near you. Apple juice is packed with nutrients and is a staple in weight loss practices. Pure apple juice is sweet, so add apple cider or lime juice for the tangy punch. 

Apple juice with an added sour flavor can replace pineapple juice in most recipes. Green apple juice is the best bet in mimicking the effect of pineapple juice.

Green apples have a more tart-like flavor with a sweet hint. if the juice is too tangy, add honey to elevate the flavor profile.

7. Passion Fruit Juice

Passion Fruit Juice

The best quality of passion fruit is available throughout the year and has a nice sweet and sour flavor. You don’t have to add any extra flavors. A glass of passion fruit is always ready to replace pineapple juice in your dish.

The color and fragrance make it an excellent choice for any cocktail or mocktail drink and dessert. The fragrance of passion fruit makes it a popular choice for scented candles and bath soaps too.

8. Papaya Juice

Papaya Juice

Want a substitute for pineapple juice with similar health benefits? Then, papaya juice is the one you need. Papaya has a sweet and mildly bitter taste. However, the sweetness in papaya is more prominent than the bitter hint.

Papaya juice can replace pineapple best in uncooked recipes. However, if you heat papaya juice, it loses its proteolytic enzyme properties. to add sourness you can add lime juice while using papaya juice in your recipes.

9. Grapefruit Juice

Grapefruit Juice

I use pink grapefruit juice to replace pineapple juice. This citrus fruit has a mind sweetness. The sweet flavor can be spiced up with 1 tablespoon of honey per cup of juice. 

It is not just a delicious pineapple juice substitute. The high level of antioxidants makes your recipe healthy to eat, like pineapple juice.

What Does Pineapple Juice Taste Like?

Pineapples are delicious when ripe. You can make drinks with it, garnish salads, make soups, and smoothies, or drink raw.

It has a sweet and mildly tangy flavor profile. However, unripe pineapples have a sour and tart-like flavor and no sweetness in them. 

The fragrance is also a part of the essence of pineapple juice.

What Can You Use Instead of Pineapple Juice in a Pina Colada?

If I am making pina colada without pineapple juice, I mostly prefer orange juice. Mix lime juice with orange juice to create a perfect substitute. I find orange juice pina colada refreshing and flavorful.

You can also experiment with other citrus fruit juices. The key is to make a balance of sweetness and tanginess in the juice.

What’s The Best Pineapple Substitute in Smoothies?

When I am too busy to make a properly cooked meal, I reach for a smoothie. So easy to make, and you can drink a healthy and tasty smoothie in a short time.

If I don’t have pineapples, I make papaya smoothies. Because it’s healthy and already has a smooth, creamy texture to it.

Mango smoothies are also very delicious. These fruits have high natural sweetness, so avoid adding extra sugar to make your delightful smoothie recipe.

Is Frozen Pineapple as Healthy as Fresh?

Well, fresh fruit is always preferable to frozen. However, ripen pineapples only have 2/3 days of life. So to store them, you have to freeze them. And frozen pineapples have almost the same health benefits as fresh ones. 

Sometimes I take out two or three pieces of frozen pineapple and put it in my smoothie instead of ice. It’s an excellent way to add more nutrition to your diet.

How Long Can Pineapple Stay Frozen?

  • To extend the lifespan of pineapples, freeze them. 
  • Peel the skin of the pineapples, and chop them into small-medium size pieces.
  • Please put them in a ziplock bag or an airtight jar and freeze them.
  • Frozen pineapples can be stored for 5-6 months.

I have experimented with all the pineapple juice substitutes in this list. These juices are nutritious and will make your taste pallet happy with their unique flavor.

Now don’t forget to mention your favorite pineapple juice recipe in the comment below. And as many substitutes as you can to add different flavors and nutrients to your recipes.

I’m a passionate food blogger on a journey to become a go-to person who can help others prepare delicious foods. I share recipes, food substitutes, and other cooking tips. Read more about my journey...

Leave a Comment