16 Best Substitute for Mushrooms

Mushrooms are a tasty, yet often avoided food due to their texture and taste. If you are looking to replace mushrooms in a recipe, don’t worry – there are plenty of delicious options to choose from! Whether you’re looking for something for texture, flavor, or health benefits, it’s likely that there is a suitable substitute for mushrooms. 

In this post, I’ll be talking about a few of the most popular mushroom substitutes that can add a delicious flavor to your recipes.

16 Substitute for Mushrooms 

The best substitute for mushrooms are tofu and eggplant. You can also use tempeh, zucchini, and sun-dried tomatoes as mushroom substitute.

For those looking for an alternative ingredient to replace mushrooms, there are a variety of options depending on the type of dish being created.

1. Tofu 


If you’re looking for a substitute for mushrooms, tofu is the perfect option. Not only does it have the same texture and taste as mushrooms, but tofu also has an umami flavor and nutritional value that make it an excellent substitute.

You can make tofu dishes in many different ways – so there’s bound to be one of your favorites on the list! Moreover, tofu is high in protein which makes it ideal for vegetarians and vegans who are looking for a healthy vegan meal replacement.

If you’re wondering if tofu is good enough to substitute mushroom recipes altogether, the answer is yes-it definitely works well in some cases! 

2. Tempeh 


If you’re looking for a meat substitute that’s both tasty and nutritious, tempeh might be the perfect option. This versatile dish can be used in different dishes, making it an ideal choice for vegans and vegetarians. It can also be seasoned to taste, ensuring that everyone will enjoy their meal.

In addition, tempeh is high in protein and fiber which makes it a good source of nutrition for people on the go.

Overall, tempeh is a great substitute for mushrooms because:

  • It has a similar texture – Tempeh doesn’t have any water content like mushrooms so they fry up similarly when cooked;
  • It’s affordable – Tempeh is relatively cheap to buy and stores well
  • Tasty flavor – Tempeh has a nutty flavor that tastes great in dishes. 

3. Zucchini 


Zucchini is one of the most popular substitutes for mushrooms. Not only does it taste great, but zucchini is also low in calories and cholesterol-free! That makes it a healthy substitute for those who are looking to lower their intake of unhealthy foods.

In addition to being delicious, zucchini can be used in various recipes such as soups, stews, and pizza doughs. It’s even been known to make eggplant taste like cheese!

Make sure you include zucchini in your diet regularly – not only will you enjoy the flavor its texture offers, but you’ll be getting plenty of benefits too! 

4. Onions/Caramelized Onions 

Caramelized Onions

Onions and caramelized onions are a great substitute for mushrooms in many dishes. They add depth of flavor to dishes that can’t be matched by other ingredients, making them the perfect choice for substitution in recipes.

Have them caramelized before using so you get the same flavor and texture as mushrooms. Caramelizing onions also provide health benefits as they contain antioxidants and dietary fiber.

Use them in place of other vegetables such as onions or carrots when cooking, or add them to soups, stews, or sauces for extra flavor and nutrients 

5. Eggplant 

How to Tell if Eggplant Is Bad

Eggplant is a versatile substitute for mushrooms and can be used in place of both Portobello and Button mushrooms.

It has a similar earthy flavor to the texture of button mushroom- so it is perfect for those who are looking to replicate the taste of these fungi-based dishes without consuming toxic toxins.

It can also be cooked in various ways, such as stir fry, baking, or even as a pizza topping- making it an ideal dish for any occasion. Though eggplant may not have the same nutritional value as some other vegetables, its health benefits make up for this shortfall. So include eggplant in your weekly meal plan – you won’t regret it! 

6. Sun-Dried Tomatoes 

Sun Dried Tomatoes

Sun-dried tomatoes are a tasty and versatile substitute for mushrooms in most recipes. They have a similar texture, flavor, and nutritional value to the fungi-y kind, making them an excellent choice for vegetarians or people who want to reduce their mushroom intake.

They can be used as a condiment or added to salads or sandwiches. Furthermore, they’re also a good source of antioxidants and vitamins A, C, and E- all essential nutrients necessary for good health.

Sun-dried tomatoes can be stored in an airtight container in the fridge for up to two weeks- ideal if you want some quick snacks on the go! Just make sure you read the ingredients carefully before using them because some sun-dried tomatoes may contain sulfites which some people are sensitive to 

7. Squash 


Squash is a great substitute for mushrooms. It has a milder taste and can be used in many dishes – from stir-fries to pizzas!

Not only does it add flavor, but squash also provides the necessary moisture content, making it perfect for those who are looking for something different in their meals. Squash can be roasted, boiled, or even baked – so there’s really no limit to how you can prepare it!

And if that wasn’t enough, its key ingredient- zucchini- is now being recognized as a health food due to its high levels of antioxidants. So go ahead and give squash a try next time you’re cooking – you won’t regret it! 

8. Artichoke Hearts 

Artichoke Hearts

Artichoke hearts are a great substitute for mushrooms because they are high in fiber and antioxidants. They can be used in place of any type of mushroom, including black, enoki, and shiitake mushrooms. Their flavor is similar to that of regular artichokes so you may not need to adjust your recipes as much as you might expect.

Moreover, artichoke hearts are low in calories and high in fiber which makes them a healthy option. You can cook them as you would cook regular artichokes or use them raw as a vegetable dip or salad dressing.

For best results make sure to get the best quality artichoke hearts available so that they taste their best when cooked. 

9. Olives 


Olives are a great substitute for mushrooms in many ways. They have a similar flavor, texture, and nutritional value to the fungi-based dish, making them an excellent choice for anyone looking for an easy substitution.

Apart from salads and dipping sauces, olives can also be used in pasta dishes or as part of the main dish – they go well with just about anything! Olives are also low calorie and high protein content so they can be enjoyed by people of all diets.

They’re easy to store and don’t require any special preparation – all you need is some chopped-up olives! 

10. Chickpeas 


Chickpeas are a great source of protein and fiber. They can be used in many dishes as a substitute for other meat-based ingredients, such as mushrooms. They are also high in potassium which helps maintain healthy blood pressure levels.

In addition to being vegetarian, chickpeas are also gluten-free making them suitable for people with dietary restrictions. Boiled, steamed or even roasted chickpeas make an excellent dish – they’re versatile and easy to use no matter the occasion!

It’s best to eat them fresh – but if you can’t wait that long, store them properly in the fridge so they remain at their best quality. 

11. Lentils 


Lentils are a versatile substitute for mushrooms in many recipes. They have the same texture and flavor, making them perfect for substitution purposes.

In addition to this, lentils are high in fiber which helps to keep you full longer and they also contain protein-rich content. Lentils can be used as an ingredient in soups or salads, with variations that can be easily created depending on your taste preferences or dish requirements.

As an added bonus, lentils are low-calorie and affordable – making them the perfect choice for anyone on a diet or looking to lower their intake of calories overall. 

12. Leeks 

Leeks Substitutes

Leeks are versatile and easy-to-use vegetables that can be used in many recipes. They have a mild flavor and can be cooked in various ways, making them perfect for vegetarians, vegans, or anyone looking for a healthy substitute for mushrooms.

They also boast high levels of nutrients such as Vitamins C and A, potassium, fiber, magnesium, and vitamin K which make them good for overall health. In addition to this, they are rich in antioxidants which help protect the body from damage caused by the sun or other environmental factors.

Leeks can be stored refrigerated for up to two weeks so you always have fresh vegetables on hand when you need them. They are also great additions to soups stew dishes or simply served as a side dish with your favorite meals! 

13. Potatoes 


If you’re looking for an easy substitute for mushrooms in various dishes, then potatoes are the perfect option. They are low-calorie and high-starch, making them a great choice when it comes to dieting or health concerns.

Additionally, they have a bland flavor that works well in substitution recipes. Boiled, mashed, fried, or roasted – potatoes can be used in almost any dish and deliver consistent results time after time.

Some of the most popular options include mashed potatoes and macaroni and cheese. They’re also cheap and easy to cook – making them the ideal choice for busy people on the go! 

14. Carrots 

How to Tell if Carrots Are Bad

When it comes to vegetables, mushrooms are the reigning king. However, many other vegetables can be just as beneficial for your health and diet – carrots being one of them.

Carrots are high in Vitamin A, potassium, and fiber which makes them perfect for a healthy meal replacement. They also have a very similar flavor profile to mushrooms so you won’t be able to tell the difference when eating them! And unlike some vegetables that need time to taste good, carrots taste great right from the start.

Cooking Carrots is one of the best ways to enjoy their flavor – try steaming or boiling them up and see what your favorite way of cooking is! There’s something for everyone on this list so make sure you include some sweet-tasting carrots in your next dish rotation! 

15. Walnuts 


Walnuts are a versatile and healthy snack that can be used in various dishes. They are also high in mono-unsaturated fats, antioxidants, and vitamins which help protect your body from damage.

They can substitute mushrooms for their texture and flavor, making them an ideal choice for those looking for something similar but different. Walnuts can also help boost your energy levels!

Apart from being good to eat on their own, walnuts can be used as an ingredient in omelets pasta sauces etcetera – giving you plenty of options when it comes to incorporating them into your meals. 

16. Umami Seasoning

Umami Seasoning

Along with bitterness, sweetness, saltiness, and sourness, umami is one of the basic sensations. It is the protein signal found in large quantities in meat, eggs, dairy, and legumes.

This flavor is frequently obtained through slow-cooking cattle or meat. The peculiar flavor of mushrooms is directly related to the umami flavor of the savory palate. So if you like mushrooms and want to replicate the flavor but don’t have fresh mushrooms, umami seasoning is an excellent option. 

The flavor goes particularly well with recipes that call for Porcini or Shiitake mushrooms, a species of mushroom that is native to Japan. Depending on the recipes and your personal preferences, you can change the umami seasoning. Additionally, it will give your soups or sauces a distinct and savory mushroom flavor. 

What Do Mushrooms Taste Like? 

The most widely available edible mushrooms have a characteristic musty or earthy flavor that is frequently compared to being slightly meaty.

Because of their meaty flavor, mushrooms are often used in place of beef in recipes that call for plant-based ingredients. 

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What can I use instead of mushrooms? 

You can use tofu, tempeh, zucchini, onions, eggplant, sun-dried tomatoes, squash, and artichoke hearts as substitutes.

2. What vegetable can be substituted for mushrooms? 

Because they are similar to mushrooms in taste and texture, you can use tofu, eggplant, or tempeh as a substitute for mushrooms.

Sun-dried tomatoes and zucchini are further substitutes. 

3. How do you make mushroom flavor without mushrooms? 

When it comes to replicating the flavor of mushrooms in food, you can substitute them with different ingredients. Some of the most popular substitutes include ginger, garlic, soy sauce, and mirin. Garlic and soy sauce are great substitutes for mushroom flavor in savory dishes as they add depth of flavor and aroma. For sweet dishes, mirin is a great substitute as it has a sweet taste and the flavor of mushrooms. 

I’m a passionate food blogger on a journey to become a go-to person who can help others prepare delicious foods. I share recipes, food substitutes, and other cooking tips. Read more about my journey...

Leave a Comment